Brothers who are not brothers

 


Hank carries a picture of him and Pauly from back when they first met at the Little Falls Laundry, having shown it to me so many times the edges are worn from his greasy fingers plucking it out of his wallet again and again.

He had someone snap the shot when they were both outside on the street in Little Falls and tries to convince me he and Pauly look alike, like brothers, and then gets angry with me when I fail to see it, though both of them have long hair, wear jeans and eyeglasses.

He needs this so much I sometimes suspect, Hank might even murder Pauly’s real brother just to take his place, and once plotted to marry Pauly’s girlfriend’s sister on the off chance he might become a brother-in-law as the next best thing.

Pauly and I don’t look anything like each other, yet we’ve grown close, he telling me stories about how long it took for his mother to give birth to him, how he ought to have been born on Christmas, delaying for three whole days of labor before finally consenting to embrace the world.

Hank couldn’t wait for Christmas to be born and hurried his arrival on Christmas Eve, expecting to get a birthday present as well as a Christmas present every year when the season comes round.

“Wouldn’t it have been amazing if we’d been born on the same day,” Hank told me once, still clutching that stupid picture and the fantasy of brotherhood even Garrick – who was born a day before Pauly – can no longer tolerate and tells Hank to “shut the fuck up.”

Garrick, Pauly and I all at the same Kindergarten teacher at St. Brendan’s although at different times, and long before we actually met, a humorous memory each of us carries as this is some other kind of bond a frustrated Hank can’t share, each of us living briefly in the same neighborhood in Paterson where we likely passed each other without knowing it, meeting years later elsewhere as strangers.

I keep thinking of how I made my mother wait for me, even though I was born in May, as if holding out for Mothers’ Day rather than Christmas, the long hours of labor in which I resisted coming into this world, somehow suspecting I wouldn’t like what I found when I got here, an amusing tidbit Pauly and I sometimes ponder along with the question of afterlife and whether or not we have been recycled like old newspaper, choosing the circumstances of our new life after having lived previous lives before.

Pauly is always off on these strange tangents when I’m with him, as if for some reason, he’s come to believe I understand him better than the others would, more than the always practical Garrick, who tells him to “shut the fuck up,” when he gets in these moods, and the always disappointed Hank who claims he would have chosen to be Pauly’s brother had he had a choice.

Pauly gets irritated when I tell him I would not have come back if I’d been here before, knowing what I know now, having seen what this place is really about, preferring birth as a death sentence than a multiple life sentence for crimes we’ve never committed, or committed in a previous life none of us can remember, that slap on the butt we all get when we first come out, our first real sense of the pain we will continue to feel until we stopped feeling pain at all.

“Don’t be morbid,” Pauly tells me when I’m in this mood with him, and then hands me the joint as if that will make me forget, making me laugh, making me grateful I don’t have a photo of us in my wallet as proof of a non-existent brotherhood we already feel a part of.

 

Main Menu

email to Al Sullivan


 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

You’re all I’ve got tonight

My Chantilly Lady

The girl across the street